You Made the List kit: two Mickey Mouse Jelly Much Eye Shadow Sticks with their gift-tag box on a red backdrop You Made the List box and two pink Jelly Much Eye Shadow Sticks, uncapped, on white Tee Hee! Jelly Much Eye Shadow Stick, ivory champagne with silver and pink pinpoints, on three eyes with a texture swatch Aww, Gee Jelly Much Eye Shadow Stick, shimmering silver with baby blue and silver pinpoints, on three eyes with a texture swatch Tee Hee! and Aww, Gee Jelly Much Eye Shadow Stick arm swatches on three skin tones You Made the List box and Jelly Much Eye Shadow Sticks among wrapped gifts and holiday ornaments
You Made the List kit: two Mickey Mouse Jelly Much Eye Shadow Sticks with their gift-tag box on a red backdrop
 You Made the List box and two pink Jelly Much Eye Shadow Sticks, uncapped, on white
 Tee Hee! Jelly Much Eye Shadow Stick, ivory champagne with silver and pink pinpoints, on three eyes with a texture swatch
 Aww, Gee Jelly Much Eye Shadow Stick, shimmering silver with baby blue and silver pinpoints, on three eyes with a texture swatch
 Tee Hee! and Aww, Gee Jelly Much Eye Shadow Stick arm swatches on three skin tones
 You Made the List box and Jelly Much Eye Shadow Sticks among wrapped gifts and holiday ornaments
You Made the List kit: two Mickey Mouse Jelly Much Eye Shadow Sticks with their gift-tag box on a red backdrop You Made the List box and two pink Jelly Much Eye Shadow Sticks, uncapped, on white
 Tee Hee! Jelly Much Eye Shadow Stick, ivory champagne with silver and pink pinpoints, on three eyes with a texture swatch
 Aww, Gee Jelly Much Eye Shadow Stick, shimmering silver with baby blue and silver pinpoints, on three eyes with a texture swatch
 Tee Hee! and Aww, Gee Jelly Much Eye Shadow Stick arm swatches on three skin tones
 You Made the List box and Jelly Much Eye Shadow Sticks among wrapped gifts and holiday ornaments
new limited edition

You Made the List

Aww, Gee + Tee Hee!

4.8
Rated 4.8 out of 5 stars
270 Reviews

💎 Multi-dimensional pinpoints of Pearl
🍮 Bouncy, Jelly formula
🖌️ 1-swipe intensity
📈 Buildable
🐭 Two shades
⏳ Long-lasting

review

4.8
Rated 4.8 out of 5 stars
Based on 270 reviews
99%would recommend these products
Reviews Summary
Customers say this eyeshadow stick glides on smoothly with a cooling sensation and dries quickly without creasing. The shimmer is buildable and stays put all day, with gorgeous, vibrant colors that blend beautifully. Many note the convenient stick format and versatility as both a standalone shadow or topper. A few mention chunkier glitter particles or subtle color payoff on certain shades.
Slide 1 selected
Write a Review (Opens in a new tab)
270 reviews
  • Maria B.
    Verified Buyer
    Reviewing
    You Made the List
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    10/28/26
    Love jelly sticks

    Easy to use beautiful colors no complaints. Nice to add to mattes as well as a tap in.

    Was this helpful?
  • Cynthia K.
    Verified Buyer
    Reviewing
    You Made the List
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    10/24/26
    Glow Sticks

    These Are So Great And Easy To Use✨ Just In Time For The Holidays

    Was this helpful?
  • Sarah S.
    Verified Buyer
    Reviewing
    You Made the List
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    10/22/26
    Got compliments!

    I love these so much! I wore the gold one yesterday and the silver today. A colleague AND a student both gave me compliments yesterday on the gold one! It was easy to use, and did not transfer on my hooded eye lids.

    Was this helpful?
  • Kelly H.
    Verified Buyer
    Reviewing
    You Made the List
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    10/21/26
    Love these new jelly shadow stix

    Super easy to use and adorable packaging

    Was this helpful?
  • Julia F.
    Verified Buyer
    Reviewing
    Real Talk
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    10/20/26
    Let’s be real

    I love the shade Real Talk, very ethereal….. I think I like this just as much if not better than the jelly much shadows, by far the best jelly shadow stick I have yet tried! Very smooth and wet looking….

    Was this helpful?
Show More